Book Review: Cookie Love by Mindy Segal

I must have at least 50 (ok ok…. maybe more like 100) baking books on my bookshelves, but somehow I always feel like I need more.

For my latest selection from Blogging for Books I decided to go for this one:

Cookie Love

I do love a cookie. Or as I would call them, a “biscuit”, because I am British, and that is how I do things.

They used to make us some really fabulous cookies at work before we moved offices, but alas now we get standard cookies, which aren’t as exciting. It is however always a better break time when I have one of those instead of when I have on occasion in desperation attempted to satisfy my cookie urges by eating one of “Grandma’s” cookies – they are an insult to Grandmas everywhere, my Grandma would never have served me such substandard baked goods!

So, about the book:

Mindy Segal is a self-confessed Cookie Nerd, handy in a cookbook writer, as it means that you know that the recipes should be well tested and tweaked until they result in wondrous cookie perfection every time.

It includes a section on tools, one on the perfect pantry for cookie baking, with suggestions for all kinds of substitutions and additions, and then of course all the recipes, divided into sections:

  • Drop Cookies
  • Shortbread
  • Sandwich Cookies
  • Egg White Cookies (kinda variations on Macarons etc.)
  • Spritz and Thumbprint Cookies (extruded European style and regular thumbprint)
  • Twice-Baked Cookies (kinda variations on Biscotti type cookies)
  • Rugelach and Kolachkes
  • Bars

A potential problem I foresee is the occasional bizarre or unusual ingredient in the recipes (Goat butter anyone?), which may make it tricky to really embrace baking every recipe from the book, but there are some fun looking recipes here, including her version of the Compost cookie – The Kitchen Sink Cookie, which I have always wanted to give a try – salty and sweet together is always a winner (my go-to work snack on non-cookie days is a handful of chocolate M&Ms mixed in with some Gardetto’s)

So is it any good? Well I gave making the Oatmeal Scotchies a go:

Oatmeal Scotchies

Yup. They kinda spread together a little. I liked the toasted oat aspect of the cookies, and the sweet and salty, but I found it a little too sweet (perhaps in part due to me finding butterscotch chips a little sickly and synthetic tasting), and a little too salty as there were 2 whole teaspoons of salt in them there cookies! (You can get the recipe for Oatmeal Scotchies here.) I gave a couple to Mr M and our visitor from England to try, and while they agreed that they were possibly a little salty, otherwise found them tasty!

Update: I also gave them to my co-workers at work…… They are addicted, so it is perhaps just me.

Maybe I just have a slightly different taste profile to the author and need to tweak the recipes to suit my palette accordingly. However there are a few other recipes in there that I fancy giving a try, like maybe the savoury biscotti for cheese as Mr M is a big cheese fan.

Does it add much to my cookbook shelf? Not necessarily. It is a nicely put together book, plenty of pictures, but the recipes are not necessarily super original, or ones that are massively different to ones I already have in other books.

As always…

I received this book for free from Blogging for Books in return for this review.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: